vs
Ignatia vs Phosphoricum acidum
(Ignatia amara · Acidum phosphoricum)
Both come up after grief, loss or disappointment.
In short
Ignatia is the fresh, sighing, changeable stage of grief; Phosphoricum acidum is the flat, listless exhaustion that can follow.
Side by side
(the classic distinctions homeopaths look for)
| Feature | Ignatia |
Phosphoricum acidum |
|---|---|---|
| Stage | Fresh, recent grief or shock | Settled grief; drained and depleted |
| Mood | Swings from laughing to crying | Listless, apathetic, indifferent |
| Signs | Sighing; a lump in the throat | Slow to answer; can't find words |
| Energy | Tense and wound up | Mind tires first, then body |
| Worse for | Coffee, tobacco smoke, morning | Exertion and being talked to |
Ignatia
Better
Eating, Changing position
Worse
Consolation, sometimes, Coffee, Tobacco smoke, Morning
Phosphoricum acidum
Better
Keeping warm, Rest
Worse
Exertion, Being talked to, Loss of fluids, Emotional strain
From the classic texts
“Mentally, the emotional element is uppermost, and co-ordination of function is interfered with.”
“Mental debility first; later physical. A congenial soil for the action of Phos acid is found in young people who grow rapidly, and who are overtaxed, mentally or physically.”
Read the full profiles
-
Ignatia
(Ignatia amara · St. Ignatius bean)
A leading remedy for fresh grief and emotional shock. Ignatia is associated with sighing, a lump in the throat and moods that swing quickly, often with contradictory symptoms.
Read more -
Phosphoricum acidum
(Acidum phosphoricum · Phosphoric acid)
The remedy of quiet, flattened exhaustion. In the materia medica, Phosphoricum acidum is associated with listless apathy after grief, illness or long strain, where the mind tires first and the body follows.
Read more
Articles that discuss both
Free printable guide
12 remedies to keep at home
When to think of each one, how to tell them apart, when to call a doctor instead and a printable home remedy guide.
Get the free guide
Still not sure which fits?
That's what a consultation is for.
Book free intro call
This page is for education only and is not medical advice. Homeopathy is complementary care, not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a licensed medical provider. Seek medical care for severe, worsening or emergency symptoms. Please view our Disclaimer.