vsCaulophyllum vs Cimicifuga
(Caulophyllum thalictroides · Cimicifuga racemosa)
Both are described in women's cycles and hormonal change, with cramping pains and aching.
In short
Caulophyllum is short, irregular cramping with wandering small-joint pains; Cimicifuga is aching muscles under a heavy, gloomy cloud.
Side by side
(the classic distinctions homeopaths look for)
| Feature | Caulophyllum |
Cimicifuga |
|---|---|---|
| Type of pain | Cramping, needle-like, short and irregular | Aching, sore, like electric shocks |
| Where | Small joints: fingers, toes, wrists, ankles | Large muscles of the neck and back |
| Pattern | Pains wander, shifting every few minutes | Worse the heavier the period |
| Mood | Weak, exhausted and fretful | Aching, restless and gloomy; talkative |
| Better for | Warmth and rest | Warmth and eating |
Caulophyllum
Better
Warmth, Rest
Worse
During pregnancy and labor, Around periods, Cold
Cimicifuga
Better
Warmth, Eating
Worse
Morning, Cold (except headache), During periods, more so the heavier the flow
From the classic texts
“Severe drawing, erratic pain and stiffness in small joints, fingers, toes, ankles, etc. Aching in wrists. Cutting pains on closing hands. Erratic pains, changing place every few minutes.”
“Sensation of a cloud enveloping her. Great depression, with dream of impending evil. Fears riding in a closed carriage, of being obliged to jump out.”
Read the full profiles
-
Caulophyllum
(Caulophyllum thalictroides · Blue cohosh)
A remedy of the womb and the small joints. In the materia medica, Caulophyllum is associated with weak, irregular or ineffective contractions around childbirth and with stiff, aching small joints whose pains wander.
Read more -
Cimicifuga
(Cimicifuga racemosa · Black cohosh)
A remedy of a dark cloud and aching muscles. In the materia medica, Cimicifuga is associated with heavy gloom, talkative agitation and stiff, achy muscles, often tied to the menstrual cycle and hormonal change.
Read more
Articles that discuss both
Free printable guide
12 remedies to keep at home
When to think of each one, how to tell them apart, when to call a doctor instead and a printable home remedy guide.
Get the free guide
Still not sure which fits?
That's what a consultation is for.
Book free intro call
This page is for education only and is not medical advice. Homeopathy is complementary care, not a substitute for diagnosis or treatment by a licensed medical provider. Seek medical care for severe, worsening or emergency symptoms. Please view our Disclaimer.